




 








|
A
shield is projected from Endor to the Death Star orbiting it. The Executor has shields, without which
it is very vulnerable to attack; concerted bombardment by the Rebel
fleet could bring these down without much difficulty.
Several critical events during the Battle of Endor display critical
weaknesses in Imperial armor against physical impact.
Two logs smash an AT-ST handily, and a rogue A-Wing smashes straight
through the forward bridge window of the Executor. The Super Star
Destroyer's command center was destroyed, and the ship plummeted to its
doom, crashing nose-first into the second Death Star. A Y-Wing is also
seen impacting an ISD, although without great consequence for the ISD.
It is possible that the shields of the ISD were up during that impact.
Empirical armor penetration formulae show penetration depth is related
to a term that ranges from V2M/A to VM1/2/A1/4,
where V is the velocity, M is the mass, and A the area of impact. As
the armoring plates' thickness would seem to be substantially lower
than the caliber of the large impacting projectiles, the first formula
is strongly suggested.
Bullet/Gun
|
Type
|
Caliber or
Impact Area
|
Mass
|
Impact velocity
|
V2M/A |
VM1/2/A1/2 |
Musket, large
|
Musket
|
.80"
|
~50g
|
~400 m/s
|
2.5x107
|
670
|
1911 Colt .45 ACP
|
Pistol
|
.45"
|
250 grain
|
750 fps
|
7.9x106
|
280
|
AK-47
|
Assault
Rifle
|
7.62mm
|
7.4g
|
715 m/s
|
8.3x108
|
3,400
|
16"/50 mk 7
|
Battleship main gun
|
16"
|
1225kg
|
762 m/s
|
5.5x109
|
6,000
|
A-Wing
|
Fighter
|
1m2
|
~6000kg
|
~150 m/s
|
1.35x108
|
12,000
|
Log
|
Dead Tree
|
1.5m
|
1.3x104kg
|
12 m/s
|
1.0x106
|
1,200
|
Y-Wing
|
Bomber
|
3m2
|
~5x104kg
|
~300m/s
|
1.5x109
|
51,000
|
The A-Wing is particularly problematic; it would appear as though the
windows of Imperial ships are unlikely to be able to resist assault
rifle fire. Clearly the hulls
are more armored; Y-Wing survival suggests a level of protection
equivalent to or
greater than 8.9" of face hardened steel.
The logs, however, condemn the AT-ST. Granted, the AT-ST's armor was
not
actually penetrated; however, while it is possible that the AT-ST may
resist some small arms fire, it is clearly not a heavily armored
vehicle.
|
ST-v-SW:
Log smashes AT-ST.
|