Starfleet Jedi

Right, as I have no idea who I will be facing, or exactly what the topic will be, I'm relying on a mod to change the thread title! This is basically an open-ended challenge, for anyone to pick up. I would imagine a 5 posts each structure, since anything else would get unwieldy.

challenge threads seem really wasteful and in the most recent cases immensely immature and petty how about you just find some one you disagree with and start something

Maybe Sothis could debate SWST? :D

No topic? Then, well, why force one? It seemed you have a gripe against RSA's double standard. Why not go at him?

Nowhereman10 wrote:Maybe Sothis could debate SWST? :D

so long as we can sell tickets to the debate

Admiral Breetai wrote:

Nowhereman10 wrote:Maybe Sothis could debate SWST? :D

so long as we can sell tickets to the debate

Well, seeing as SWST and myself are both in what you would call the 'pro-Warsie' camp, it would also be meaningless.

I am quite happy to debate RSA, if he has the time, but like I said before, I can't stick to a rigid structure.

Sothis wrote:Right, as I have no idea who I will be facing, or exactly what the topic will be, I'm relying on a mod to change the thread title! This is basically an open-ended challenge, for anyone to pick up. I would imagine a 5 posts each structure, since anything else would get unwieldy.

The challenge is to open ended. I'm not sure who would want to debate everything Star Trek and Everything Star Wars.

Lucky wrote:

Sothis wrote:Right, as I have no idea who I will be facing, or exactly what the topic will be, I'm relying on a mod to change the thread title! This is basically an open-ended challenge, for anyone to pick up. I would imagine a 5 posts each structure, since anything else would get unwieldy.

The challenge is to open ended. I'm not sure who would want to debate everything Star Trek and Everything Star Wars.

Well, whoever picks up the challenge gets to pick the exact topic.

Sothis wrote:

Admiral Breetai wrote:

Nowhereman10 wrote:Maybe Sothis could debate SWST? :D

so long as we can sell tickets to the debate

Well, seeing as SWST and myself are both in what you would call the 'pro-Warsie' camp, it would also be meaningless.

I am quite happy to debate RSA, if he has the time, but like I said before, I can't stick to a rigid structure.

Oh no, I think it'd be quite funny to watch and see which of you two can wank up Star Wars the most, don't you? ;-)
-Mike

Sothis, think of the pro-trek, or anti-Wars argument that you think is the worse, and start the debate with this...
For example:
-Trekkie n 1: Ha! The DS couldn't hurt the Enterprise, because it's a Superlaser and lasers don't even penetrate the navigational deflectors...
-Warsie n 1: WTF? Do you really believe that? It's impossible because...

And then the debate starts... :)

Honestly, I agree. You really should put up a properly focused debate challenge. Or just make a new topic and let whomever wished to participate in it dictate how it goes.
-Mike

If you're looking for a suggested topic, I would say FTL navigation and transportation.