*sigh* an uninformed and terrible post as usual.
StarWarsStarTrek wrote:Hey, here's a foolproof method of any Star Wars galactic civilization trumping an Alpha Quadrant civilization!
I'm waiting in anticipation.
Potential objections:
Where do they get enough ships? - The ISD's alone outnumber the amount of, say, Federation planets. One alone is big enough to store several thousand nukes.
Laughable. You have no clue what the number is for the total number of planets and you're just stating that they will basically have enough. You havn't even watched enough star trek to know what 'enough' is, unless you've been tanking it really hardcore since your first time here.
Where do they get enough nukes? - even most Trekkies concede that fusion technology is very, very, very common in Star Wars, so much that random citizens can afford fusion powered starships.
Tactics not generally used, or used as a one off tactic, or something that is not taught as a dedicated doctrine are not viable. We couldn't claim that the federation would fight with solar flares (even though this is a demonstrated capability) because they don't use it very often as a tactic. The Empire in T and G cannon do not utilize nuclear bombs for such purposes.
Their use in the EU is rare at best.
How do they find the ST planets? - just get it by bribing a random ST traveler. It's not as if, say, the Federation keeps planet locations secret; Archer sent the coordinates to Earth to a random alien race they just contacted.
You provide no peramiters to the nature of the link of the galaxies. You provide no data that anyone will actually provide them such information without an even exchange.
Furthermore, you provide absolutely no evidence as to how they make first contact with anyone in the first place. It's just as likely they encounter 8472 or the Borg before they encounter random civilization that just magically knows where all the dominion AND federation planets are.
How do they plot the hyperspace routes? - they don't need hyperspace routes, and even if they did it's really just a matter of time.
Citation needed. Dedicated hyperspace routes are absolutely critical to war efforst, furthermore hyperspace routes can be mined, blockaded, and other wise rendered useless in any manner of ways (gravity being one of them, something the fedreation has mastered to a heavy extent). You provide zero evidence and your claim, as such, is dismissed.
Why can't the Federation strike back? - because warp drive is slow, there are too many SW planets (planets outnumber ships in this case) and too many are shielded.
You provide no data for the nature of the theater of war, you can make no claim for if the federation can or can not strike back till then. Just because warp drive is 'slow' means nothing if the federation encounters the rebellion who preceed the empire and grant hyperdrive to all the races out of the kindness of their hearts. Making up shit is real easy.
A hundred million kilometers? Wank! - not against a planet in a predictable orbit, no. Especially since cross-star-system firing against stationary targets/predictable targets have happened in NJO.
So the missiles will just not be intercepted because? Once again you fail even the most basic form of common sense... all of this are magical wankaton missiles with wankaton shields impervious to attack because you say so.
What about surviving ST ships and space stations? - >99% of the population would be dead, and the remaining ships and such couldn't do jack.
Baseless assumption is baseless.
Why can't the planet's defenses intercept the missiles? - they have not shown the accuracy or reaction times to do such a thing, and they can't intercept all of the missiles.
Yes because you've clearly seen all of trek and know all their speed and reaction times, and politely ignore any thing that contradicts your vision of it.
Simply put, imho your entire post was full of nothing but BS. I mean low grade BS at that. This was low, even for you.
Answer honestly, have you seen all of ENT, TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, and the movies? If not, maybe you should go watch some stuff first. For that matter have you seen all six movies, the clone wars cartoon, and read the thrawn triology at the very least in star wars... I have heavy doubts you understand ANY of the source material you reference, and you constantly seem to repeat nothing but same old arguments irregardless of how often they've been refuted.
Pick a single topic, don't pose useless scenarios, and actually open your mind up... maybe you'll find something more interesting than whatever on earth that pile of crap up there was supposed to be...
On a final note, I'm still waiting for your replies in several other threads, or have you conceded those points, accepted my accusations, or willingly decided not to provide evidence that I asked for?
