Mith wrote:Broken Link: The Defiant is said to have enough firepower to reduce the Founder Home World to a cinder.
Various degrees of interpretation.
When you have several torps and the ability to fire many phaser pulsers backed up by a warp core possibly containing hundreds of kg of antimatter or maybe more, you have more than enough firepower to turn a planet into a burning waste land if you fire intelligently.
The Survivors: Alien ship was stated to have enough firepower to pulverize a planet.
It was an episode involving a sort of god-like entity which could decide that forty megawatts worth of pseudo firepower could suddenly threaten the shields of the E-D when they didn't previously.
Deja Q: Came up with a plan to push away a falling moon
By using a combination of two systems with wonky physics, right?
The Perfect Society: Managed to divert a stellar core
And yet failed to slightly budge a moon?
A Time to Stand:
O'BRIEN'S COM VOICE
I've got eighty-three empty
canisters standing by.
(a beat)
And one not so empty. Ninety
isotons of enriched ultritium
should take out the entire storage
facility and anything else within
eight hundred kilometers.
Anyone else have anything to add?
But the visuals show something different. Instead of having a sudden powerful explosion which would be the only possible way for the chemical explosive to live up to its pretense, the asteroid base is actually damaged by a few first very puny explosions when the explosives go off.
I don't exactly know how those things work, especially for chemicals, but obviously there was something funky at play there.
I'd like this bit covered because it's important to get fixed on the mechanism of this element.
Apocalypse Rising:
There's be little surprise that a large base would be powered by a more hefty power source, whatever it is.
It was a Bird of Prey. Klingons and Starfleet see things differently when it comes to starships, and who to put in them.
We've seen BoP pose a threat to the E-D in one on one engagements, like with the Duka sisters if I'm correct.
It's possible that a Galaxy-class could be a tad better or not.
In the end, if such a ship carried, say, a total of +100 torpedoes, a Klingon crew onboard such a ship would have no problem to take care of targets over a hundred of kilometers wide area, with torps in the 2 digits megaton range. Remember that Damar didn't account for the shield in his figure. Odo corrected him there.
Laying waste to a world - see "The Chase" for a single Klingon ship doing that. It wipes out (almost) all life on a world;
It was a chain reaction continuing on its own, no?
The Klingon ship couldn't fire when cloaked.
See also "Tears of the Prophets," in which plasma torpedoes are used to destroy a rather large asteroidal moon with not too many hits.
The torps only did moderate damage. The power source on this asteroid is responsible of its own destruction.
Actually, if we consider "Pegasus" carefully, the asteroid is likely to be larger and more massive, and any attempt to destroy the Pegasus within the asteroid is likely to involve a lot of wasted energy. It turns out that "Pegasus" isn't any worse than "Rise" regarding yields. The fact that they could blow up the fairly massive moon of "Deja Q" is quite similar, actually. Both asteroids are tens of kilometers wide and probably at least in the e16 kg range of mass.
What was the size of the asteroid Pegasus? I have pictures of the scalings, but not the size of the E-D (height) nor the size of the asteroid.
Wasn't it around 10 km?
If we're going to talk about ambiguous references, the Delta Flyer's warp core, breached, has a minimum safe distance of a million kilometers in "Drive."
Possibly due to a lethal concentration of particles estimated low enough at such a distance.
The range itself is not believable. An explosion of a mere Delta Flyer couldn't possibly represent a real danger to structures at a million kilometers, even if that was the radius of the spreading sphere.
Then there's "Dreadnought." On the ridiculously high end, it supposedly could blow up a small moon, and is a warp powered vessel in its own right - should be more dangerous than an exploding Delta Flyer; on the low end, it's a superweapon whose warhead is a mere thousand kilograms of antimatter - which means 2000 kg of matter annihilated, releasing 1.8e20 joules - 43 gigatons.
It's not ridiculous. A small moon can be small, as it's put.
If you want to check out the likely absolute low end interpretation of a small moon, check out
Dactyl.
The fact that the ship and its power were considered impressive and pointed out as a big menace clearly gives a nice reference for what to expect from ships and smaller weapons in general.
It also means that the warhead's own explosive yield would be considerably more important than the power source used for beam weapons and shields.
I'll talk about the rest later on.