2046 wrote:Mr. Oragahn wrote:2046 wrote:
No, it most certainly did not. You cannot have a dark sky on the one side and a bright twilight glow with bright pink clouds on the other, and you cannot claim that buildings which are not as brightly lit in the lesser twilight are therefore viewed through tinting. There is little to no significant difference in, for instance, the building self-illuminated in yellow.
For the first claim, please explain what you're trying to tell me in details, I fail to understand your point. I don't see where I claimed there was a dark sky on any side.
You are claiming equal brightness between the office shots and the out-the-Senate-window shot, while simultaneously we have the Senate exterior shot. Ergo, you are claiming we can have a dark sky on one side and a bright twilight glow with bright pink clouds on the other.
No.
I don't claim any dark sky on any side. I don't see where you get that.
This image clearly shows that what darkens the sky on the left is the clouds, while the sky itself is clearer.
I perfectly know about the very intense moonlight as a matter of fact.
That said, the exterior shot of the senate during night doesn't show where the sun comes from, and it's likely something like behind the camera, on the left, which would explain the small pink tint on the right of the image, which lets us enough room to suggest that there's more unseen pink twilight offscreen, behind the camera.
Which incidentally is pretty much what you claim on this picture:
The only thing that is darker is the senate sector seen through the corridor window of the sort of promenade Windu takes to join Yoda.
The reduced intensity of the artificial lights precisely show that the window is tinted, which lets people considered that it's the same dawn.
This image precisely shows that there's the moonlight on one side, and the pink sunrise tint on the other
Scarce tinting . . . hardly what I described or what we can see.
What we can see from Palpatine's office, or from the promenade's window, those buildings we point at in many pictures, can't be seen on the external night shot of the senate.
My point is that the buildings in question are somewhere "south east" of the senate on that picture, which is why there's more pink tint in the sky behind them.