In essence he argued that the plasma torpedoLucky wrote:So what did he/she say? I'm not asking for an exact quote
A). Vaporized an asteriod about 2 miles in diameter and therefor was in the gigaton range in terms of yield
B). Could travel at warp speed, fast enough to keep up with the Enterprise, and therefor could strike an IOM ship 100% without fear of being intercepted.
C).Had light minutes range based on it running at full warp for a minute or so before dissolving.
Now all of this is displayed in the actual episode and while obviously should be open to debate,while I agree the weapon had those ranges I don't think the Romulans could target at such extreme range, what he got instead nitpicks and mental gynmanstics to deny what happened onscreen. My faveriot is when one suggested during the chase scene that the Plasma torpedo was hitching a ride on the Enterprise's warp field despite no suggestion or remote hint that such a thing was occuring.
Such is life. Its not what you know but who you know. :)Lucky wrote:I've noticed good points are often ignored based simply on who made them.