So after going through trouble of designing a sealed suit they itenitonally put in a contrived valve that can't be manually sealed?2046 wrote:It's called a valve. A simple mechanical valve that gets blown shut when interior pressure is higher than exterior would be of value.
I can in fact claim they are vacuum worthy since we saw them operate in vacuum.2046 wrote:In any case, though, my main point is simply that you cannot declare trooper armor to be vacuum-worthy based on the podhunter episode.
Further, given that you have contradictory indications regarding trooper armor (not airtight one minute, a pressure suit in the next), then you can either assume variants of the trooper armor (an extra entity where only one is obvious) or something minor like a valve or pressure-related (doesn't even have to be electronic) inflation (also an extra entity).
A third option would simply be that they used the SW equivalent of duct tape in the pod to seal up the gaps in the armor before going outside. Frankly that idea seems pretty damn good to me, but as we did not see any evidence of that I thus lean away from it.
Hence my statement that we ought not draw final conclusions until more evidence is forthcoming, because no answer is perfect and, most importantly, the series continues.
The episode is contradictory only if you refuse to ackonwledge various explanations already given in the thread: carelessness by the troopers, damaged suits, lack of air filtration system etc.
Also why would someone design a suit that is duct tape away from being space worthy and then stop there? Not that it matters since the clones obviously had an air supply which means the suits are designed to operate in vacuum.
Finally no matter how many more episode there are they won't change what we saw in the second episode.
I'm not saying you should care but you are required to provide reasoning as to how it's physically possible otherwise your theory is void.2046 wrote:Why should I care?
You need to provide some reasoning and numbers behind your absurd concentration claim. Also how do you know there were additional screams by a single clone rather than single screams by several clones.2046 wrote:That would be an absurd concentration. Further, how do you get a guy to inhale such things for the additional screaming we heard?