The white council vs The Jedi council?

VS debates involving other fictional universes than Star Trek or Star Wars go here, along with technical analysis, detailed discussion, crossover scenario descriptions, and similar related stuffs.
Picard
Starship Captain
Posts: 1433
Joined: Mon Aug 31, 2015 8:28 pm

Re: The white council vs The Jedi council?

Post by Picard » Thu May 26, 2011 10:18 pm

Yes, they are most powerful Jedi that existed, and Sidious probably is most powerful Sith that existed. But that wasn't a question. Question was >>>>>>>why the heck Sidious does not display any of wanktastic powers that Expanded Universe gives him whatsoever??????<<<<<<<< At least in his second fight with Yoda, objective was to kill, yet we never see such powers. Now, since you are obviously half-blind for arguments you don't like, I have bolded it to you, and put within nice set of arrows pointing to it, meaning you shouldn't have any problem finding question, and after that, answering it.

Admiral Breetai
Starship Captain
Posts: 1813
Joined: Mon Aug 31, 2015 8:28 pm

Re: The white council vs The Jedi council?

Post by Admiral Breetai » Fri May 27, 2011 3:05 am

StarWarsStarTrek wrote:

Sidious has been stated by numerous sources to be the most powerful sith lord of all time,]
statements mean nothing when not backed up by feats show the movies overule the EU as Sidious in two of the most desperate fights of his life never showcased power any where near any ancient sith or jedi...the mere fact that he failed to do this in the films completely nullifies any statements to the contrary
StarWarsStarTrek wrote:]and Yoda has been stated in the AOTC novel to be the most devastating foe the darkness has ever known, putting Yoda as the most powerful Jedi prior to EU Luke.
and yet none of Yodas EU feats where shown when he was in a desperate battle for his life to slay the dark lord...at no point did he show any major feats that fuck even an apprentice from Revans era would be impressed with once again the lack of evidence in the films nullifies anything else
StarWarsStarTrek wrote:And your arguments against Sidious's power is because...he barely survived two fights. Well, you did not quantify the people of whom he fought; both of whom were perhaps the two most powerful Jedi Masters in recorded history by that point, so your analysis is paper thin.
this is it this reply right here you show that you are intentionally and deliberately misreading peoples arguments and distorting them to avoid facing the argument- the level of power of his opponents is irrelevant the mere fact that in both fights neither party showcased any of those EU feats despite Sidious not holding back at all being desperate and both times nearly loosing his life

the absolute lack of those feats from either parties when it would matter the most absolutely nullifies any EU claims any more lies you wanna spew?

Picard wrote:Yes, they are most powerful Jedi that existed, and Sidious probably is most powerful Sith that existed. But that wasn't a question. Question was >>>>>>>why the heck Sidious does not display any of wanktastic powers that Expanded Universe gives him whatsoever??????<<<<<<<< At least in his second fight with Yoda, objective was to kill, yet we never see such powers. Now, since you are obviously half-blind for arguments you don't like, I have bolded it to you, and put within nice set of arrows pointing to it, meaning you shouldn't have any problem finding question, and after that, answering it.
English is not Picards primary language yet he immediately grasped what I was getting at you have no such excuse

you're intentionally distorting and misreading arguments

Post Reply